Should You Trade in a Car with Negative Equity?

Trading in a car with negative equity is a decision that many car owners face, especially when upgrading to a new vehicle or dealing with financial strain. Negative equity—also known as being "underwater" or "upside-down" on a loan—means that you owe more on your car loan than the vehicle's current market value. While trading in a car with negative equity is possible, it comes with financial implications that you should carefully consider. In this guide, we’ll explore what negative equity is, how it affects your trade-in options, and whether trading in your car is the right move for you.

Understanding Negative Equity

What is Negative Equity?

Negative equity occurs when the remaining balance on your auto loan exceeds the resale or trade-in value of your vehicle. For example, if you owe $20,000 on your car loan but the trade-in value is only $15,000, you have $5,000 in negative equity.

Causes of Negative Equity

Several factors contribute to negative equity, including:

• Depreciation: Cars lose value quickly, especially in the first few years of ownership.

• High-interest loans: If you took out a loan with high interest rates, more of your initial payments may go toward interest rather than reducing the principal.

• Small or no down payment: Financing a car with little to no money down can increase the risk of negative equity.

• Long loan terms: Loans with terms of 72 or 84 months may result in slow equity buildup.

Trading in a Car with Negative Equity: What Are Your Options?

1. Rolling Over Negative Equity into a New Loan

One of the most common ways to trade in a car with negative equity is rolling the remaining balance into a new auto loan. However, this means you will start your next loan already owing more than the new car’s value, potentially leading to a cycle of debt.

Pros:

• Allows you to get a new car despite negative equity

• Simplifies payments by consolidating the remaining balance

Cons:

• Increases the total loan amount and monthly payments

• Can put you at risk of further negative equity

2. Paying Off the Negative Equity Before Trading In

If you have the financial means, paying off the negative equity upfront can help you avoid rolling it into a new loan. This may involve using savings, bonuses, or other sources of income.

Pros:

• Avoids carrying over debt into a new loan

• Reduces financial risk in future vehicle purchases

Cons:

• Requires a lump sum payment, which may not be feasible for everyone

3. Delaying the Trade-In and Paying Down the Loan

If you don’t urgently need to trade in your car, waiting while making extra payments can help reduce or eliminate negative equity.

Pros:

• Reduces financial strain in the long run

• Helps you build positive equity before trading in

Cons:

• Requires patience and commitment to additional payments

4. Selling Your Car Privately

Private sales often yield higher resale prices compared to trade-ins, which may help cover more of your loan balance.

Pros:

• Potentially get a better price than a dealership trade-in

• Reduces or eliminates negative equity

Cons:

• Takes more time and effort to find a buyer

• You may still need to cover any remaining loan balance

5. Considering Refinancing

If your negative equity is due to a high-interest loan, refinancing to a lower rate could help reduce your payments and build equity faster.

Pros:

• Can lower interest rates and monthly payments

• Helps pay down the principal faster

Cons:

• Requires good credit and lender approval

• May extend the loan term, depending on the terms

Should You Trade in a Car with Negative Equity?

When It Makes Sense to Trade In:

• You Can Afford the Higher Payments: If rolling negative equity into a new loan won’t strain your finances, trading in may be a viable option.

• You Need a More Reliable Vehicle: If repair costs on your current car outweigh the benefits of keeping it, trading in may be worth considering.

• Interest Rates Are Favorable: If your new loan offers significantly lower interest rates, the overall financial impact may be minimized.

When You Should Hold Off on Trading In:

• Your Loan Balance Is Significantly Higher Than the Car's Value: The more negative equity you carry over, the deeper in debt you’ll be.

• You’re Struggling with Payments: Adding more debt could worsen your financial situation.

• Your Credit Score Could Be Affected: A higher loan balance could increase your debt-to-income ratio and impact your creditworthiness.

How to Minimize Negative Equity in Future Car Purchases

1. Make a Larger Down Payment

Putting down at least 20% when purchasing a new car helps offset depreciation and reduces the risk of negative equity.

2. Choose Shorter Loan Terms

Opt for a 36- or 48-month loan instead of a 72- or 84-month loan to build equity faster.

3. Buy a Car That Holds Its Value Well

Some brands and models depreciate slower than others. Research resale values before purchasing.

4. Avoid Rolling Negative Equity into Future Loans

Carrying over debt repeatedly can keep you trapped in a cycle of financial strain.

Conclusion: Weigh Your Options Carefully

Trading in a car with negative equity isn’t always the best financial move, but in some cases, it may be necessary. Before making a decision, consider all your options, evaluate the financial impact, and determine what works best for your situation.

Call to Action

If you're struggling with negative equity and unsure of your best course of action, consult with a financial advisor or auto loan specialist. Understanding your options can help you make an informed decision and avoid costly mistakes.

Keywords used: trade in a car with negative equity, negative equity car loan, car trade-in options, upside-down car loan, car loan refinancing, roll over negative equity, paying off car loan, private car sale, new car loan impact, how to reduce negative equity.